SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
 issue44Formación y gusto por la escritura y la lectura a luz de las ideas de Friedrich Nietzsche como ámbito de estudio de la ducación corporalUma visão antropológica da aplicação de questionários na pesquisa em educação author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Share


Educar em Revista

Print version ISSN 0104-4060

Abstract

ANDRADE, Erika Natacha Fernandes de  and  CUNHA, Marcus Vinicius da. Concordâncias e discordâncias de Dewey com Freud. Educ. Rev. [online]. 2012, n.44, pp.275-291. ISSN 0104-4060.

This article exposes Sigmund Freud's ideas about themes which are fundamental to the comprehension of the contemporary man: the psychic constitution; the formation and resolution of mental pathologies; the broad meaning of culture and the education as a mediating element between individual and society. This paper aims to present and compare the analysis made by John Dewey regarding these same themes based on the book Human nature and conduct. The comparisons between Freudian and Deweyan discourses are made through the methodology proposed by Chaïm Perelman in the book Treatise on argumentation (co-authored by Olbrechts-Tyteca), which aims to clarify the argumentative strategies used by an author to obtain or increase adhesion to the proposed theses and, with that, to awaken concrete actions. The conclusions suggest that although Dewey disagrees with Freud, they agree on certain issues, especially regarding the meaning of impulses and sublimation and regarding the conception that knowledge is changeable and imprecise, what rejects the belief in absolute certainties and inserts human actions and decisions in the sphere of probability.

Keywords : John Dewey; Sigmund Freud; Psychological Discourse; Education; Rhetoric.

        · abstract in Portuguese     · text in Portuguese     · Portuguese ( pdf )