Abstract

MENDES, Geisa do S. C. V et al. Self-evaluation as a strategy of resistance to the ranking external evaluation. Educ. Pesqui. [online]. 2015, vol.41, n.spe, pp.1283-1298. ISSN 1678-4634.  https://doi.org/10.1590/S1517-9702201508144828.

This article discusses the current meaning of the evaluation policies in and of school, presenting a study carried out by Brazilian and Portuguese researchers, with the participation of twenty public schools in the cities of São Paulo and Campinas (Brazil) and Porto (Portugal). Theoretically anchored in the Participatory Institutional Evaluation and Negotiated Quality approaches, the research involves the schools’ professionals and also sectors of education administration, through the study groups in each of the universities. The article critically addresses the expertise function of the research that frequently legitimizes evaluations centered on products and thus lends credibility to standardized tests and to the proliferation of the so-called evaluocracy, with consequent changes in the school inspection and management procedures, and also in the management of education systems. These changes corrupt/deform the concept of school autonomy and favor the proliferation of concession schools, stimulate the use of education vouchers, as well as the increase and naturalization of school inequalities and a certain representation of the Knowledge Society, which promotes vocational training for the working classes, recreating a dual education system. In contrast, this study argues for the possibilities of a virtuous circle between education, research and extension as a method of relation with public schools, starting from the concept of Negotiated Quality that, together with professionals and community in every school, initiates self-evaluation processes, with the intention of transformation and developing new relationships within and outside the school, reinforcing the strategic learning of a collective competence of social actors in favor of public school social quality.

Keywords : Participatory Institutional Evaluation; Public policy; Self-evaluation; Negotiated quality.

        · abstract in Portuguese     · text in Portuguese     · Portuguese ( pdf )